Monday, February 10, 2014

Earth Friendly De-Icer?

I've been looking for the earth friendly alternative to de-icing. What information I've found suggests the troubling aspect of our use of de-icers is that we use them wrong. We use too much and not how they are intended to be used. For example, I see my neighbor throwing the name brand de-icer on our 5 inches of snow accumulations. Turns out it is completely ineffective for anything over 3 inches. They point out de-icer should only be applied to roads that have been plowed or sidewalks that have been shoveled.

As for choosing a de-icer, I choose none. However, if you must choose....Philadelphia's call for safer treatment of website includes this information:

Salt Alternatives (from phillywatersheds.org)


  • Calcium magnesium acetate (CMA) is the most environmentally friendly de-icer. Northern states use CMA on roads in sensitive areas (wetlands, drinking water supply, etc.). However, CMA does not work well below 25° Fahrenheit and it is the most expensive de-icer.
  • Corn byproducts are effective de-icers recycled from mills and breweries. However, they can have extremely high phosphorus content, a major water pollutant.
  • Chloride (salt-based) products such as potassium chloride, calcium chloride and magnesium chloride are less harmful to the environment than salt. Check product labels for chemical content to find them at your local hardware store.
  • Chloride products often perform best when used in combination with salt. They will increase efficiency by reducing the amount of salt necessary.
  • Sand can be used in conjunction with any of these de-icers to add traction.
  • No comments:

    Post a Comment